I may love this strawberry version of my popular funfetti cake more than the original! Although the other is a favorite cake that I took a long time to perfect, this version is much easier to make as it’s a sheet pan not layer cake. It will definitely take less time to make than a layer cake so opt for this when you just don’t have it in you to fuss around.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1908a/1908a6c95d118880b769501158cf26b44edc31fc" alt=""
While developing my funfetti cake recipe, I road tested just about every other vegan recipe out there and they all came up short for me. They either didn’t have the right texture, or flavor and were just disappointing. I’ve been baking since I was a kid and I remembered a book I bought when it came out in the late 80s called “The Cake Bible” by Rose Levy Beranbaum. I made so many cakes (all in my pre-vegan days) from this book and I recalled she had an unusual method of incorporating ingredients and I went to my bookshelf to grab my well worn copy and started reading the recipes again. Yep, she had written about a revolutionary method of adding the fat to the dry ingredients FIRST before adding the liquid ingredients. It’s come to be known as the “reverse creaming” method and it guarantees a moist cake with an incredible texture. It’s a method used in commercial bakeries although they usually use vegetable shortening and not oil like I am in my recipe.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54a4f/54a4f62ecf3814265cfd044b9cfd0a8d30488ea8" alt=""
What is reverse creaming?
Reverse creaming refers to the way the ingredients are combined and in what order. Traditionally, the wet ingredients are mixed together first, the dry whisked together then added to the wet just until combined. This is because over-mixing will cause the batter to form gluten and be tough if you do over-mix. With reverse creaming you add the fat to the dry ingredients first (in this recipe it’s the yogurt and oil) and that coats the flour preventing it from absorbing moisture and forming gluten. When the rest of the wet ingredients are added, it’s almost impossible to over-mix and form gluten. The crumb is also finer and the rise better with this method especially for vegan baked goods.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b1a4/4b1a461e6e77c6c42cbd1faeb7a4f631fb4e3a06" alt=""
Another amazing benefit of reverse creaming is that everything is mixed in one bowl. You really should use a stand or hand mixer for this but you could mix it by hand with a whisk. The dry ingredients are all blended together first to break up any lumps and then the oil is added with some vegan sour cream (for tenderness) and some of the vegan milk then mixed completely. Then you add the rest of the milk which we’re adding some lemon juice into for some lift from the acid and then the magical extracts. More about those after the photo jump.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/be6a2/be6a2af87ca5e2a1bbd6623c9967f69c349ec64b" alt=""
What gives cake that magical funfetti flavor?
Two options: cake batter flavor extract or clear imitation vanilla. I know, I know, Ina Garten only uses “good” vanilla but that just won’t give the cake that bakery flavor. Cake batter extract (I use McCormick brand) is what I prefer. It does color the cake a slight yellow but that’s fine. I grew up using Duncan Hines yellow cake mix and it replicates that flavor. Clear imitation vanilla is also another solid choice and it’s what I like to use in the frosting. I’ll add the extracts to my Amazon store (link at the bottom of the recipe) and the vegan sprinkles I use. More about sprinkles after the jump.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ac2d7/ac2d77c1a13464d85078b2f7704ca387145bc1cb" alt=""
About vegan sprinkles.
Aren’t all sprinkles vegan? They’re just sugar right you might ask? Wrong. Most are made with confectioners glaze which has shellac in it derived from insects and colors can also be questionable. Vegan sprinkles are available online at some retailers (both Kroger and Whole Foods Market sell their own private label versions) but they’re usually way more pastel than their traditional bright intensely vibrant counterparts and tend to dissolve more into the batter. No judging If you use regular sprinkles but for a truly vegan cake you may have to forgo the fireworks in the cake itself and just be satisfied with a ton of them on the outside!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/afce3/afce3de28ceb8dc3b1307221dbe400476bce8308" alt=""
What makes this cake special.
- Freeze dried strawberries in the frosting that you crush in a food processor! (One cup should yield about 1/4 cup ground.)
- The powdered fruit colors the frosting a light pink!
- Note: You could use freeze dried raspberries or another freeze dried fruit if preferred.
I hope you enjoy this cake for special occasions, events or just on a Tuesday because you’re worth it!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9f1a3/9f1a3cef8c631dfc28295be3e641f2369342c31d" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1b10b/1b10bedf674c17386f1fc4a6015153821d55a2ab" alt=""
Pingback: 15 Best Funfetti Sheet Cake Recipes To Try Today
I made this (with a different vegan strawberry frosting) for my daughter’s birthday and it was a huge hit! Best non-chocolate vegan sheet cake I’ve tried so far.
Love that! So glad you enjoyed for your special occasion. Thank you so much for the kind review!
Question how do you think this might work with strawberry yogurt instead of plain 🤔
I’ve never thought of that but think that might work great! If you try it, report back!
Is there anything that I can use instead of vegan yoghurt or sour cream? Also is there a substitution for corn starch?
Sorry I don’t suggest any other substitutes for the yogurt or sour cream. If you try something else know that it’s at your own risk and might not bake as expected. As for cornstarch, you could substitute potato starch or arrowroot. Thanks!