I’ve been trying to make a classic pecan pie or bar for years with no success. I’ve tried so many egg substitutes and nothing produced the right results. They either didn’t coagulate or were so runny or stodgy that they were nothing like the pies I remembered before going vegan. I had high hopes for Just Egg because although it can be unpredictable in certain baked goods, this was more of a filling for a pie. I’ve used Just Egg in a number of my recipes and what I’ve found is a little aquafaba (liquid from canned chickpeas) is it’s friend. I don’t know why or the science behind it, but it helps. I think the reason is that Just Egg acts like the yolk and aquafaba as the egg whites. Sometimes using all Just Egg has left baked things a little dry in my experience and we don’t want that in a pecan pie filling! Now, some may balk at the price of Just Egg but I liken it to any other specialty ingredient you may buy like a good vegan butter, artisan chocolate or a really good vanilla. I don’t think you’d be making these every week, so it’s more of a special recipe where you might want to splurge on an ingredient to make it really great.

These are loaded with pecans. Pecans in the crust and the filling. The base is a short crust like a butter cookie and the filling is so perfectly silky and unctuous. And the best part? NO CORN SYRUP! Most recipes call for this ingredient but I used a dark raw agave and it came out just like the pecan pie filling I remembered. I think maple syrup would be too thin, but a product like Britain’s Lyle’s golden syrup might work here as well.

I originally made these plain and even toyed with the idea of adding pumpkin to replace some of the egg, but then I thought it might not set. Once finished, I thought they needed something to counter all the sweetness. But what? Then it came to me, chocolate of course! A drizzle of a dark bittersweet chocolate was the perfect foil to the sweetness. I had cracked it finally and I now present them to you.

Make sure to trim the ends all around before cutting into squares. The edges can get a bit tough. I find cutting with a serrated bread or tomato knife is best and cut them when they’re cold and refrigerate any you don’t finish, but let’s be honest, that might not happen.

I’m not sure if using all aquafaba would produce the same results as using the combination with Just egg. If you were to try it, I would suggest using one cup then adding 3 tablespoons of finely ground flax seed. I know Just egg is not available everywhere so if you try another egg replacement that works, drop a comment below!


If I don’t have justegg, can i just do 1 whole cup of aquafaba?
Yes, I mention that in the blog post that I suggest if you use all aquafaba that you add some flax meal to it. I would suggest 3 tablespoons to the one cup of aquafaba. Let me know how it turns out!
Once again you transformed a traditional dessert into a delicious vegan recipe that is absolutely delicious!! Let the creativity continue.
Awesome, so glad you liked them! I’ll keep on creating!
can I use Maple syrup instead agava?
I have not tried pure maple syrup and normally it’s thinner than agave but it should work! The classic sweetener in these pies is corn syrup but I know a lot of people avoid it. Brown rice syrup would work as well I think. Report back if you try it!
Pingback: The Best Vegan Pecan Pie – Big Box Vegan